Every now and then I review the notes I took during my master’s degree modules to check if there’s anything that newly sparks inspiration for a story.
One line which I’ve come back to several times – but never written about until now – is something I scribbled during an early modern London (c.1500-1750) lecture about social hierarchy and power structures.
It says: “the most dangerous person was the single woman”.
In its simplest terms, it shows the patriarchal culture of the era. Men were considered stronger – both physically and morally – and therefore superior to women. As a result, women needed constant supervision, protection, and control, first by their father, then their husband.
This wasn’t just for their own good, but for everyone else’s good, too.
In their book, ‘Women in Early Modern England’, Sara Mendelson and Patricia Crawford put it like this: “In the eyes of society, all masterless women were disorderly by nature, and were moreover the stimulus for misconduct in others.”
In 1563 the Statute of Artificers was introduced to legally force women who weren’t under the control of a parent or husband into work, so they could be controlled by a master or mistress employer instead.
It gave local officials the power to order single women between the ages of 12 and 40 into service ‘for such wages and in such reasonable sort and manner as they shall think meet’. In Norwich, in the east of England, for example, single women were sent to jail if they didn’t find suitable work within a certain time limit.

Technically, the statue could be applied to men, but Mendelson and Crawford say they “have found no evidence of the Act being applied to adult men in the same way as to women”.
They did, however, find examples of it being applied to some women who were under parental control – if that parent was their mother, rather than their father. This, they say, underlines the “patriarchal assumptions behind the statute”.
“Women’s sense of personal autonomy must have been affected by their awareness that only females, not males, could be forced into service.”
Economics was a key element to the fear of masterless women; that they couldn’t support themselves without the assistance of a father or husband. This is evidenced by the fact the Statue of Artificers was only applied to women of the ‘labouring class’, rather than ‘propertied’ women, who were far less likely to need to rely on anyone, or any local authority, for financial assistance. (Another casualty of the Statute of Artificers, this time in Salisbury in southwest England, was first whipped for being a vagrant and then ordered back to her home parish for them to ensure she was employed or support her otherwise.)
Mendelson and Crawford also draw attention to the age range of the women the statute applied to – 12 to 40-year-olds – and its correspondence to their potential to get pregnant. It was, therefore, “intended as a sexual as well as a physical and economic constraint on young women’s liberty”.
Indeed, as Eleanor Janega has written: “The assumed sexual profligacy of women meant that an unaccompanied woman was often read as a theoretical threat. There was no telling what a woman alone, without a man’s supervision, might do.”
She explains that in some cities in this period, “women were required to join households rather than live on their own” or at the least, “had to live together with other unsupervised women”.
Christine Peters has described a similar regulation in Coventry, in central England, as being about “a fear of the masterless”, but more specifically: “It seems that the city fathers greatly feared the moral risk of women dwelling alone within the town because of their belief in the insatiable female sexual appetite”.
But what’s interesting to note is that amid all this panic and penalties, many women did remain single in early modern England and found ways to achieve independence.
Professor Amy M Froide has done significant and fascinating work looking at single women in this period. She’s found they made up around 30% of the adult population of women in England; at least 33% in urban areas. She’s also found that women at all social levels (although, more frequently in the ‘middling’ and ‘genteel’ classes) were capable of controlling their own finances and that some even played an active role in the late-17th to early-18th Century ‘Financial Revolution’, making up to 33% of investors in bonds, annuities, government funds, and lotteries. (I’m going to come back to this topic in another post.)
I spoke to Professor Froide recently to better understand the context around the fear of masterless women in this era of England’s history. She told me:
“In the early modern period you have a society that’s totally hierarchical, that is obsessed with order – social order, political order – and that’s obsessed with family as the basis of that order, and thinks that everyone has their place.
“In that, the single woman should be quite low in the hierarchy, and she should have others who are supervising and controlling her. And so, if you have a woman who’s not embedded in a family with a patriarch, or in a job with an employer who’s watching over her, then she’s violating that order.”
But, as Professor Froide’s own research has shown, “this is the ideal more than the reality”.
“In the 17th Century, especially, you have this rising number of women who are putting off marriage – maybe not by choice, but just by reality. [On average, English women didn’t marry until 26 at this time.] And then the more women who put off marriage, well, some don’t marry at all. So, there’s rising numbers of single people. Then the anxiety really ratchets up as people realise they’ve created a system where the ideal is no longer working.”
She agreed that, yes, the fear of masterless women was about sex, but even more so, about money.
“The assumption is that if nobody’s watching over them, if they’re not embedded in that ideal hierarchy, they would be immoral, engage in sex outside marriage, and produce children outside of traditional families, and therefore become a charge on the state.
“So, it’s morality, but it’s all about welfare and having to pay for these women’s sins, essentially.”
And what about the suggestion that masterless women were disorderly by nature and could be a corrupting influence on others?
Professor Froide says: “In my work I’ve thought a lot about singleness by choice and singleness by circumstance. Those who do choose to be single, I do wonder if they may have been persuasive on others. It has been interesting that many times when you find a single woman in a family, there’s other single women [around them].
“So, I do think there’s some kind of influence on each other, even if it’s merely that ‘it’s okay to be single’.
“I think we’ve over-generalised the stereotype of the spinster and the assumption that it was automatically negative. In reality, there’s so many of them in people’s families. It’s more common than we recognise.”

Indeed, Professor Froide says she did so much statistical work at the beginning of her career because otherwise she wouldn’t have been able to convince people these women existed. Single women are among the historical characters we know the least about.
“I’ve always been interested in women I feel aren’t being studied, or we don’t think about enough.
“At first, a lot of scholars were very sceptical that I would find anything. They said there weren’t any single women; everybody married.”
However, “when I started looking, single women were everywhere. How could we miss this? But I realised I needed numbers. And once I had them, my numbers really shocked people, and then they were willing to listen to my arguments.”

So, how dangerous was the single woman in early modern England?
Professor Froide says: “I think humans historically have not been rational about the people or things that they fear. They often choose to fear powerless people, which is more about scapegoating than maybe true fear.
“So, masterless women were seen as a social problem, yes, with the major concern that they would bear children out of wedlock, which would be a charge on the local community. But were they feared? That’s probably not exactly the right word.”
Instead, she says, “you could look at it from the perspective of these women representing the downfall of social order, which was based on the patriarchal family. Masterless women certainly could make people uneasy because they defied that order. And in early modern England, social order was of high value.”

Sources:
Amy M Froide, Never Married: Singlewomen in Early Modern England (2005); Silent Partners: Women as Public Investors during Britain’s Financial Revolution, 1690-1750 (2017).
Eleanor Janega, The Once and Future Sex (2024).
Sara Mendelson and Patricia Crawford, Women in Early Modern England (2003).
Christine Peters, ‘Single Women in early modern England: attitudes and expectations’, Continuity and Change, volume 12 (1997).




I am here to tell you that people are STILL afraid of single women today.
As I read your piece this morning - and having lived in the Middle East for more than two decades, the similarities are striking. Both in the fear around single women and the social and structural handcuffs and/or guardrails in place.
Part of it, I think, has always come from the idea that women are responsible for the morality of men rather than allowing that men are responsible for their own moral character and decisions. The phrase “raw meat to a feral cat”is still commonly taught in much of the world, and altho I suspect the wording was different, the idea was popular across the board before western enlightenment.
Of course, we still hear it in present day discourse around what a female victim was wearing or drinking or such nonsense. So there’s that.
Thanks for the book rec and for getting bf me thinking a bit more deeply this morning over my iced latte 😉